Skip to main content
SolveComply

CA vs Accountant vs Tax Consultant: Who Should You Hire?

The difference between a Chartered Accountant, an accountant and a tax consultant: qualifications, what each can legally do, typical work and which one your business needs.

By SolveComply team
4 min read
On this page
  1. How do they compare?
  2. What does a CA do for a business?
  3. What does an accountant do?
  4. What does a tax consultant do?
  5. What about Company Secretaries and Cost Accountants?
  6. Which one does your business need?
  7. Common mistakes
  8. FAQ
  9. Find the right professional
  10. Related guides

A Chartered Accountant (CA), an accountant and a tax consultant all work with numbers, but they are not interchangeable. A CA is a member of the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India (ICAI) and is the only one who can sign statutory and tax audits. An accountant keeps your books. A tax consultant prepares and files returns and advises on tax, without the audit powers of a CA.

Quick answer: Hire an accountant for day-to-day bookkeeping, a tax consultant or GST practitioner for routine return filing, and a CA whenever you need an audit, certification, complex tax advice or representation before tax authorities.

How do they compare?

Chartered Accountant (CA) Accountant Tax consultant
Qualification ICAI membership after the CA exams and articleship Commerce degree or training; no licence required Varies; may be a tax practitioner or enrolled GST practitioner
Statutory audit of companies Yes (practising CA) No No
Tax audit Yes No No
Certifications (net worth, turnover, MCA forms) Yes No No
Bookkeeping Yes, usually via their team Yes, core work Sometimes
Income tax and GST returns Yes Can prepare Yes
Representation before tax authorities Yes No Within their authorisation
Typical cost Highest Lowest In between

What does a CA do for a business?

  • Statutory audit of companies, and tax audits when turnover limits are crossed.
  • Certifying documents for banks, MCA filings and government schemes.
  • Tax planning, business structuring and advice on transactions.
  • Representation in assessments, notices and appeals.
  • Virtual CFO work: financial planning, fundraising support and reporting.

What does an accountant do?

  • Records sales, purchases, expenses and payroll.
  • Reconciles bank accounts and GST credit.
  • Prepares monthly reports and draft financial statements.
  • Keeps records ready for the CA and auditor.

See the accounting checklist for small businesses.

What does a tax consultant do?

  • Prepares and files income tax, GST and TDS returns.
  • Advises on routine tax matters and deadlines.
  • Handles GST registration and simple notices, within their authorisation.

What about Company Secretaries and Cost Accountants?

  • A Company Secretary (CS), a member of ICSI, handles company law compliance: board meetings, AGMs, ROC filings and secretarial audits. See ROC compliance.
  • A Cost Accountant (CMA), a member of ICMAI, handles cost records and cost audits where required.

Which one does your business need?

Situation Hire
Just started, few transactions Accountant, with a CA for the annual return
GST-registered, monthly returns Accountant or tax consultant, with a CA for review
Private limited company CA for the audit and tax, CS for ROC compliance
Turnover above the tax audit limit CA
Tax notice or assessment CA or tax lawyer
Raising funds CA, often as a virtual CFO

Common mistakes

  • Relying on an unqualified accountant for filings that need CA certification.
  • Paying a CA's rates for routine bookkeeping.
  • Changing advisers every year, losing continuity on records.

FAQ

Can an accountant file my income tax return?

Yes, anyone can help prepare and file a return. But if your accounts need a tax audit, only a CA can sign the audit report.

Is a CA necessary for a small proprietorship?

Not always. Many small proprietors use an accountant or tax consultant and consult a CA for complex matters or audits.

How do I check that a CA is genuine?

Ask for their ICAI membership number and verify it with ICAI. On SolveComply, every CA's membership is verified before their profile goes live.

Find the right professional

Compare verified CAs, CSs and tax experts on SolveComply by price, rating and delivery time. Browse professionals or request a free callback.

Sources: ICAI, ICSI. Who may sign which certificates is set by law and professional regulations.

Published · Updated
This guide is general information, not legal or tax advice for your situation. Rules and fees change; check the official source or ask a verified professional before you act.

Share this guide

About the author

SolveComply team

Practical guides from the SolveComply team on registrations, tax, legal and compliance for Indian businesses.

Get it done with an expert

Need help with Accounting & Finance?

Compare verified CAs, CSs and lawyers with upfront prices. The professional is paid only after the work is delivered.

Services mentioned in this guide

Get it done by a verified professional, with the price agreed upfront.

Keep reading

All articles →
Accounting & Finance 4 min read

Accounting & Finance

Accounting Checklist for Small Businesses in India

Daily, weekly, monthly, quarterly and year-end accounting tasks for small businesses, the books to keep, how long to keep records and common bookkeeping mistakes.

SolveComply team

4 min read
Business Registration 6 min read

Business Registration

How to Start a Business in India: Complete 2026 Guide

A step-by-step guide to starting a business in India in 2026: choosing a structure, registering it, getting PAN, GST and licences, and setting up compliance from day one.

SolveComply team

6 min read
Business Registration 4 min read

Business Registration

Private Limited Company vs LLP: Key Differences

Private limited company or LLP? Compare ownership, liability, fundraising, compliance, audit and tax side by side to choose the right structure for your business.

SolveComply team

4 min read
Chat with us on WhatsApp

Are you sure?